Mahdi Darius Nazemroaya is a sociologist, award-winning author and geopolitical analyst.
Published time: December 30, 2013 08:46
Reuters/Morteza Nikoubazl
Is the interim nuclear deal signed at the end of 2013 a signal of Tehran’s surrender, or is it the opening of a new chapter in American-Iranian relations that could see the normalization of ties?
If history is to be learned from, normalization with Washington will also come with risks for Iran.
Rouhani won the 2013 Iranian presidential elections by gaining the support of the overwhelming majority of Iranians with approximately 51 percent of the popular vote. His main opponent and the candidate with the second highest number of votes was the mayor of Tehran. Mayor Qalibaf only received about 16.5 percent of the popular vote. The other four candidates (Jalili, Rezai, Velayati, and Gharazi) respectively earned 11.31 percent, 10.55 percent, 6.16 percent, and 1.22 percent of the vote. Many Iranian voters saw these candidates as virtual clones of one another and distinguished Rouhani as the one that offered an alternative program.
The consensus president
In Washington there has been a tug-o’-war between the neo-con and realist camps about how to deal with Iran. The realists have now come out on top.
In Tehran there has also been a parallel tug-o’-war over Iranian foreign policy. The political tug-o’-war in Tehran has seen the reformists and pragmatists contesting the principalist and conservative camp about how to deal with the United States. With the election of Hassan Rouhani the balance in Tehran has changed and loosened the dominant hold of the principalists and conservatives in the Iranian political arena.
Despite the fact that he received the endorsement of the reformist camp and all its supporters, Hassan Rouhani is not the Iranian reformist that some have portrayed him as being. His supporters said that Rouhani would undo the damage that President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad’s government had caused. Skeptics, however, phrase it like this: “Rouhani was the least bad candidate.”
The fact that he was the only presidential candidate that had ties to all the different political groupings in Iran was what set Rouhani apart from the other candidates. His career as a security guru in Tehran, with deep connections to the national security and military structures of Iran, and his history of working with pragmatists and reformers made him acceptable or, at a very minimum, bearable for all the different political cliques in Tehran. In the sense that he has not excessively embraced reformist or conservative tendencies, he has been a genuine moderate so far.
Iran's President Hassan Rouhani (Reuters/Adrees Latif)
Iran's President Hassan Rouhani (Reuters/Adrees Latif)
Rouhani made it clear that his administration would work for consensus among all of Iran’s political factions through a centrist political program. Since the 2009 protests over the re-election of Ahmadinejad the political divisions and polarization in Iran were sharpened. This is why Rouhani’s messages to the Iranian political establishment, as well as all of Iranian society, were ones calling for political unity and consensus politics.
In his first speech as the president of Iran, Rouhani would highlight his platform of reconciliation and diplomatic recalibration: “Let our hearts be cleansed of resentment. Let conciliation replace estrangement and let friendship take the place of animosity. Let this take place. Let Islam’s compassionate face, Iran with its reasonable face, the Revolution with its human face, and the political system with its kind face continue to create epics.” Making sure not to aggravate Mahmoud Ahmadinejad and his supporters, he would also thank them during his speech: “At this point I must thank and express my appreciation to the previous administrations, especially the Tenth Administration and its honorable former president, and for all of them I have the desire of success day by day.”
Iran’s “Yes, We Can” man and grand negotiator
President Rouhani presented himself as a negotiator par excellence during the election campaign in 2013. His promise to negotiate with the US and to lift the economic sanctions by changing the dynamics of Iranian diplomacy proved to be very popular with the business class and most of the middle class. “Moderation in foreign policy is neither surrender nor conflict, neither passivity nor confrontation. Moderation is effective and constructive interaction with the world,” he announced as president-elect. Rouhani’s inauguration ceremony on August 3, 2013 even marked the first time that foreign dignatories were formally invited to an Iranian presidential inauguration ceremony, which signaled Rouhani’s intentions to launch his diplomatic charm offensive.
Using a spiritual tone, Rouhani let it be known during his first speech as president that he intended to get results, would not let partisan politics get the better of him, and would not silence his political critics: “I feel the heavy weight of these votes and this endorsement. And I seek refuge in God and God alone. I sincerely and humbly ask the compassionate Lord: O Lord, save Thy weak servant from the ills of arrogance and conceit, greed, avarice and envy. O Lord I take refuge in Thee from autocracy in opinion, haste in decision making, putting personal or group interests ahead of those of the public, and from the silencing of the mouths of rivals and critics. O Lord, help me so that I can be Your sincere server and a competent servant of the people and not to forget what happened to those who came before me. There is much to say, but time is short. It is best to cut the talk short and to walk the path. For the path to our goal is long and I am a new traveler.”
In many ways, the fanfare and popularity that Rouhani has received and enjoyed in Iran can be compared to that which Barak Obama received in the US when he was elected. Rouhani carried a message of hope for many Iranians. The closing words in his inauguration speech were even turned into a song with a black and white video by Iranian artists just as how Obama’s speech at the 2008 New Hampshire primary was turned into a hit song by artists in the US. The video dedicated to President Rouhani was a copycat version of the Obama video that was produced by Hussein Dehbashi, who produced Rouhani’s election video ads. The Office of the Iranian President would later post the Iranian “Yes, We Can” video on Rouhani’s YouTube page.
Tehran does business with Washington
Iranian Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif (2nd L) shakes hands with US Secretary of State John Kerry (AFP Photo)
Iranian Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif (2nd L) shakes hands with US Secretary of State John Kerry (AFP Photo)
As soon as Rouhani became president, he selected Mohammad Javad Zarif to become Iran’s foreign minister. Jalili was replaced as the secretary-general of the Supreme National Security Council of Iran and the nuclear negotiations between Iran and the P5+1 were taken over from the Supreme National Security Council by the Iranian Foreign Ministry.
Zarif was selected as foreign minister not only because he was an excellent diplomat; Rouhani shrewdly selected Zarif for his experience as Iran’s interlocutor with the United States. Before his appointment as Tehran’s foreign minister, Zarif had served as the permanent representative of Iran to the UN in New York City, from where he served as Tehran’s contact man with the US government and US officials. Foreign Minister Zarif himself has stated that he and US Vice-President Joe Biden share a friendship.
As one of the pillars of the Iranian national security establishment, Rouhani himself also has had a long history of dealing with US officials. In the past it was Rouhani that held secret talks with US President Ronald Reagan’s government on behalf of Iran. In this regard, he was one of the Iranian officials who negotiated the arms transfer agreement with Washington during the Iran-Iraq War that led to the Iran-Contra scandal. More recently, Rouhani dealt with the US as the secretary-general of the Supreme National Security Council of Iran during the presidency of Mohammed Khatami.
It is no coincidence that US backtracking on attacking Syria led to talks with Iran and a warming of relations. In actuality the talks with Iran had started before the US backed down from bombing Syria. Rouhani’s government had begun dialogue with the US from the moment its mandate commenced. There are enough grounds to suspect that the threats to attack Syria also had the aim of working to gain traction in the secret talks that President Obama was having with Iran via the Sultanate of Oman.
The political taboo of dealing with the US publicly has been broken by President Rouhani. Since the start of his term, Rouhani authorized Zarif to meet with US Secretary of State John Kerry. Rouhani himself held a brief, but historic, phone conversation with President Obama. Finally, an interim nuclear deal was reached between Iran and the P5+1, more specifically the United States.
Iranian-American rapprochement
In 1993, Zbigniew Brzezinski, the realist par excellence who served as US President Jimmy Carter’s national security advisor, announced that “Iran is clearly an aspirant to regional hegemony and it is prepared to outwait the United States.” Brzezinski explained that the Iranians had an imperial tradition as a great power and possessed both the religious and nationalist motivation to contest the US and Russia, and that Iran could count on the sympathies of its neighbors in such a rivalry. Because of Iran, in his own words, “the current American supremacy in the Middle East is built, quite literally, on sand.”
Yet, that is not all Brzezinski has said about Iran. He stated that “it is not in America’s interest to perpetuate American-Iranian hostility.” He even went out of his way to warn US policy makers that Iran should not be antagonized by the US government to the point where Tehran would ally itself with Russia and China. Instead Brzezinski pushed for reconciliation as an aim of realist-driven US foreign policy. “Any eventual reconciliation [between the US and Iranian governments] should be based on the recognition of a mutual strategic interest in stabilizing what currently is a very volatile regional environment for Iran,” he explained.
The “volatile regional environment” that Brzezinski mentions is formed by the three regions that are linked to Iran: the Caucasus, Central Asia, and the Middle East. What he really meant was that Tehran and Washington should work together to influence these regions. Although it is unstated, what Brzezinski has in mind is a plan to get Iran to realign with the US in these regions against Russia and China.
The possible negative ramifications of US-Iran rapprochement
Critics of Rouhani see him and Zarif as surrendering to US demands as part of some type of internal regime change in Tehran. Such critics have argued that Iran has surrendered to Washington, whereas others have seen the interim nuclear agreement as a victory for Iran. Since Rouhani started negotiating with the US, Supreme Leader Khamenei has been forced to defend Rouhani and Zarif. Khamenei has warned the principalists and conservatives in Iran not to interfere in Rouhani’s negotiation efforts or to portray Rouhani and Zarif as traitors. “They are our own children and children of the Revolution,” Khamenei publicly declared on November 3, 2011.
Among the Iranian Revolutionary Guard and the political hardliners in Tehran, there are fears that the interim nuclear deal will lead to an even broader agreement and a normalization of relations with the United States that could potentially open the door for alterations in the political structure of Iran and give the reformists the upper hand. There were reserved statements released in November 2013 by Revolutionary Guard leaders, days before the interim nuclear agreement was reached, which assured the public that Iran’s ideology would not change, and that Iran would not bow down to any foreign powers.
Iran's supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei (AFP Photo)
Iran's supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei (AFP Photo)
As mentioned earlier, Rouhani’s government has pro-business characteristics. In this regard, there are legitimate concerns that go beyond politics which fear that restored relations with the US could see an opening up of the Iranian economy based on the neoliberal economic policies that many of the reformists—and pro-business conservatives—had embraced and favor that will see the state infrastructure and the public sector in Iran privatized further. If business ties are restored between the US and Iran, and there is a lot of talk about it, the Iranian government could entrench the Iranian economy on a path of neoliberal reforms and privatization. These would be similar to those that marked the Yeltsin years in Russia, which made an elite few rich and let foreign corporations plunder the Russian economy.
Then there is the worst case scenario of Iran being used against its Eurasian partners. The insulation of Eurasia is incomplete without Iran. The Russian and Chinese need for a strategic Iranian partner is a component of any defensive strategy or viable alternative against US and EU encroachment into their geopolitical spheres of interest. The US may attempt to use its rapprochement with Iran to manipulate Tehran into hurting Russia and China. Iran’s ethnic, cultural, linguistic, and historic links with the countries of the Caucasus and Central Asia could be used to launch an offensive against Moscow in the post-Soviet space, whereas Chinese energy security would be jeopardized if Iran agreed to collaborate with the US in any strategy against the Chinese.
Eurasia or nothing!
Although the Iranian political establishment is immensely more sophisticated than Libya, Tehran should not ignore how American-Libyan rapprochement ended and at what expense. Colonel Qaddafi even predicted it when he told the Arab League many years ago that the US had no loyalty to any of its Arab clients or friends, and that one day it could execute him.
The mere fact that the US government and its allies have a different interpretation of the interim nuclear deal from Iran, China, and Russia is reason to pause with caution too. Of course this could be posturing to appease certain segments of public opinion, lobby groups, and US allies (e.g., Israel and Saudi Arabia) that are threatened by any rapprochement between Tehran and Washington. Yet, the fact that the EU has also refused to lift certain unilateral sanctions is reason enough for Tehran to be cynical.
Iran’s place is in Eurasia. It would be a disaster if any rapprochement between the US and Iran came at the expense of Iranian-Russian ties or Chinese-Iranian ties.
To his credit, Rouhani’s first foreign trip as president of Iran was to Kyrgyzstan in September 2013 for a meeting of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, which is spearheaded by Russia and China.
While being realistic, one should always hold onto hope. Iran’s “Yes, We Can” Man and his endeavors will hopefully not end up being the epic disappointment that his American counterpart, President Obama, has been for the people of the United States.
The statements, views and opinions expressed in this column are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of RT.
RT News
Showing posts with label China. Show all posts
Showing posts with label China. Show all posts
Monday, December 30, 2013
Wednesday, May 22, 2013
China's Li offers to help end Pakistan energy crisis
China's Li offers to help end Pakistan energy crisis
Wed, May 22 04:43 AM EDT
By Nick Macfie
ISLAMABAD (Reuters) - China and Pakistan should make cooperation on power generation a priority, Chinese Premier Li Keqiang said, as Islamabad seeks to end an energy crisis that triggers power cuts of up to 20 hours a day, bringing the economy to a near standstill.
Li arrived in the Pakistan capital under extra-tight security on Wednesday on the second leg of his first official trip since taking office in March after a visit to Pakistan's and China's arch rival, India.
Li's plane was escorted by six air force fighter jets as it entered Pakistan air space. Security measures also included shutting down mobile phone networks across the city.
Pakistan was one of the first countries to switch diplomatic allegiance from Taiwan to China, in 1950, and Li told a lunch attended by Prime Minister-elect Nawaz Sharif and President Asif Zardari that China and Pakistan should remain "trustworthy partners" and good neighbors.
In an interview with Pakistan media, Li said there was still "great potential" for the relationship. Bilateral trade last year rose above $12 billion for the first time and both sides are aiming to reach $15 billion in the next two or three years.
"Our two sides should focus on carrying out priority projects in connectivity, energy development and power generation and promoting the building of a China-Pakistan economic corridor," Li said.
The power shortages have sparked violent protests and crippled key industries, costing hundreds of thousands of jobs in a country already beset by high unemployment, a failing economy, widespread poverty, sectarian bloodshed and a Taliban insurgency.
There are several joint energy and infrastructure projects under way in Pakistan and China has taken over operation of the strategically important Gwadar port.
When complete, the port, which is close to the Strait of Hormuz, a key oil shipping lane, is seen opening up an energy and trade corridor from the Gulf, across Pakistan to western China, and could be used by the Chinese Navy, upsetting India.
Li this week offered India a "handshake across the Himalayas" and said the world's two most populous nations could become a new engine for the global economy - if they could avoid friction.
China and India disagree about large areas of their 4,000 km (2,500 mile) border and their troops faced off for three weeks last month on a windswept Himalayan plateau where they fought a brief but bloody war in 1962.
Pakistan and India have fought three wars, two of them over disputed Kashmir.
"PRAGMATIC" MILITARY COOPERATION
India has responded cautiously to Li's overtures, partly because of China's friendship with Pakistan. For its part, Beijing is concerned about India's growing relations with the United States.
"I wish to reiterate solemnly China's continued firm support to Pakistan in its efforts to uphold independence, sovereignty and territorial integrity," Li said in a possible reference to India and to the United States, which angers many with drone strikes targeting militants in Pakistan.
Pakistan is going through a turbulent chapter in its ties with the United States, which plans to withdraw most of its troops from neighboring Afghanistan in 2014. Many U.S. officials have questioned Pakistan's commitment to fighting Islamic militancy since U.S. forces tracked down and killed Osama bin Laden in a garrison town near Islamabad two years ago.
China's Xinhua state news agency said Beijing was looking for "pragmatic" military cooperation with Pakistan, "which is in the front line of the fight against international terrorism".
"The military exchanges are not directed against any third party and contribute to peace and stability in both the region and the whole world," it said in a commentary.
Pakistan's Nation newspaper said Islamabad wished China well in its attempts to address its border and security concerns.
"It is also good that Premier Li is not oblivious to the kind of ill-will resulting from the core issue of Kashmir," it said.
In a brief security scare in southern Karachi on Tuesday, a roadside bomb exploded near the seafront which police said was likely aimed at a passing van full of Chinese port workers. No one was hurt.
(Additional reporting by Ben Blanchard in Beijing; Editing by Raju Gopalakrishnan)
=
Enter the dragon: China offers help to end Pakistan’s energy woes
By Sumera Khan / Kamran Yousaf
Published: May 23, 2013
Share this article Print this page Email .
Chinese Premier Li Keqiang and President Zardari chat as they leave after a joint press conference. PHOTO: AFP
ISLAMABAD:
Chinese Premier Li Keqiang has offered his country’s help in resolving Pakistan’s worsening energy crisis, as he kicked off a two-day official visit to Islamabad on Wednesday.
Deviating from standard protocol, Pakistan’s entire civil and military leadership were present at Nur Khan Airbase, Chaklala, to receive Premier Li when he arrived in Pakistan on the second leg of the visit that also took him to India. Amid tight security, the Chinese premier received a warm welcome as his plane entered Pakistani airspace, escorted by six Pakistan Air Force JF-17s.
Li held formal talks with the Pakistani side, led by President Asif Ali Zardari and Interim Prime Minister Mir Hazar Khan Khoso, reviewing “the entire gamut of Pakistan-China relations”, according to a statement issued by the foreign office. At a joint news conference with President Zardari, he stressed the need for increased cooperation between the two countries in the energy sector.
“Our two sides should focus on carrying out priority projects in connectivity, energy development and power generation,” Li told reporters at the President House. His offer to address Pakistan’s energy woes comes at a time when the country is facing extensive power outages, which have sparked violent protests.
China is already assisting Pakistan in several energy projects that include nuclear reactors. It has already provided two reactors, each with a capacity of 300MW, at Chashma in Punjab. The two countries are also planning to build two more reactors with the same capacity.
Plan to develop ‘economic corridor’
Li also said the two countries were working to develop an ‘economic corridor’ that will not only spur economic activities but also restore peace in the region.
“Both sides are of the view that by connecting China and Pakistan we can create a joint economic corridor linking the central and western parts of China and Pakistan,” he said.
“This vision, once realised, will have great strategic significance for development, peace and stability in China, South Asia and the rest of the continent, and improve the lives of people in our region.”
The Chinese premier, who was also awarded Pakistan’s highest civil award, the Nishan-e-Pakistan, pointed out that there is great potential for the two countries to enhance their bilateral trade to $15 billion from the current $12 billion over the next two years.
Speaking at a luncheon hosted in his honour, attended by incoming prime minister Nawaz Sharif among other political leaders, the Chinese premier said he selected Pakistan for his official visit to give a clear and loud message to the international community that “whatsoever happens at the international scene, our relations with Pakistan will continue to flourish and strengthen further.” He reaffirmed China’s unflinching support to Pakistan’s sovereignty and territorial integrity.
President Zardari responded by saying, “Today is one of the happiest days of my life. Gwadar port and our agreements on satellite connectivity among others are a testament to the fact that the dreams of citizens from both the countries are being realised.”
MoUs to promote bilateral cooperation
According to a foreign office statement, a total of 11 agreements have been signed between China and Pakistan as part of efforts to further deepen ties.
The agreements include memorandums of understanding (MoUs) on maritime cooperation, boundary management, border ports, economic and technical cooperation and cooperation in the field of satellite navigation.
Separately, the visiting Chinese high-powered business delegation signed procurement agreements worth $450 million to help Pakistani businesses utilise the tremendous potential of China.
Meanwhile, Premier Li will have a busy schedule today (Thursday). His engagements include an address to the Senate, a meeting with Nawaz Sharif and a joint call by the services chiefs.
Published in The Express Tribune, May 23rd, 2013.
======================
Monday, March 05, 2012
The New Silk Road Lucrative Sino-Gulf ties will survive Syria clash
05 March 2012 | By Una Galani
Russia has been roundly criticised in the Gulf for vetoing last month’s United Nations Security Council resolution on Syria. China, which also vetoed the resolution, has come in for much less flak. This may be partly because the Gulf Arab countries see Moscow rather than Beijing as Bashar al-Assad’s main supporter. But it is also because the Gulf and China have $90 billion a year in bilateral trade. It’s in the interests of neither that this is disrupted.
China and Gulf Arab countries value keeping politics out of business. The Syrian conflict, though, is testing that position. The Gulf nations want to see the end of the Assad regime: partly because of the killing of thousands of fellow Sunnis; and partly because their main enemy is Shi’ite Iran and the Assad regime is its top ally. Beijing, by contrast, strongly values the principle that countries should not intervene in the internal running of other states. It doesn’t want foreigners meddling in Tibet and Xinjiang.
The Middle Kingdom depends on the Middle East to meet its huge energy needs. The six-nation Gulf bloc supplied 34 percent of China’s total crude imports in 2011, according to Chinese customs data. That’s roughly three times the amount it imported from Iran.
But the Gulf can’t just cut off Beijing. Not only is China an important customer. It is, in turn, a supplier. For example, China is helping Saudi Arabia to increase the kingdom’s oil refining capacity and build giant railways connecting its holy cities. The pair also recently signed a civil nuclear cooperation agreement that supports Saudi’s ambitious domestic energy targets.
Beijing has softened its position somewhat on Syria in the past week. Not only did it express “deep disappointment” at Syria’s failure to allow the U.N. humanitarian aid chief to visit the country. It condemned “violence against innocent civilians” while reiterating its opposition to “armed interference or pushing for regime change”.
Beijing will probably hope it can hold this line and still keep good commercial links with the Gulf. But if the Syrian conflict escalates, it may need to modify its position further – perhaps even abstaining from rather than vetoing future resolutions criticising Assad.
==
Context News
China called on the Syrian government and all parties to cease all acts of violence, “particularly violence against innocent civilians”, in a statement on March 4. Beijing also urged the United Nations or an impartial body to distribute humanitarian aid to the Syrian people, while saying it opposed “anyone interfering in Syria’s internal affairs under the pretext of ’humanitarian’ issues.”
The foreign ministry statement also said: “China does not approve of armed interference or pushing for ’regime change’ in Syria, and believes that use or threat of sanctions does not help to resolve this issue appropriately.”
China and Russia joined other U.N. Security Council members on March 1 in expressing “deep disappointment” at Syria’s failure to allow the U.N. humanitarian aid chief Valerie Amos to visit the country and urged that she be allowed in immediately. In February, China and Russia vetoed a U.N. Security Council resolution that supported a call by the Arab League for Bashar al-Assad to step aside as president. ===================== China’s scientific outlook By: Marvi Memon | November 16, 2012 China’s foreign policy under its new leadership will be defined by an age old, well thought out strategic vision. As a great believer of China’s “scientific outlook” vision, I was most encouraged to see this continuity element in the full text of Resolution of the Eighteenth National Congress of the Communist Party of China on the Revised Constitution of the Communist Party of China adopted at the Eighteenth National Congress of the Communist Party of China on November 14, 2012: “The Scientific Outlook on Development is a scientific theory that is both in keeping with Marxism-Leninism, Mao Zedong Thought, Deng Xiaoping Theory and the important thought of Three Represents and is in step with the times.” Of perhaps all the emerging powers, China’s sense of direction is least known for knee-jerk reactions and most known for a long-term view of the world. Something Pakistani foreign policy actors need to learn from. Today’s world in Chinese terminology is called “yichao duoqiang”, which sees the world as unipolar as well as multipolar simultaneously. It is seen as a transitory process towards multipolarity. It is in this realistic context that Chinese foreign policy interventions will be relevant to all of us. This realistic acceptance is coupled with the theory of “shi”, which identifies the dominant power pole in the world order, and an assessment of whether the power configuration can bring any harm to China. From this derives the concept of following the general tendency, which will lead China higher in the power projections or “Shunshi erwei”. This process-oriented approach to foreign policy is unique to China and the new leadership is expected to make its first deliberations in the same light. The last policy direction clearly spelt out by President Hu in 2009 is worth remembering at this stage: (i) profound transformation; (ii) a harmonious world; (iii) common development; (iv) shared responsibility; and (v) active engagement. The general direction going forward will be basically the same. However, keeping in view the current international priorities, there will be a pull and push at China for a role, which is more attune with its new economic leading world status. Many in China believe that it should lead more and incorporate “retribution and punishment” in its foreign policy narrative. Its involvement in “global governance” discourse will certainly be encouraged by the EU, since its leadership role will be sought on issues like climate change, nuclear proliferation coupled with a commitment to the MDG goals of the UN. However, what is going to be watched most carefully going forward is whether there will be a more flexible approach to China’s “responsible stakeholder” role, which expects it to be more collaborative interventionist. China is unlikely to be pushed into any such misadventure by the West in its eagerness for asserting its global leadership role because it goes contradictory to its “shi” and identity. The unique nature of Chinese foreign policy is built around its emphasis on “relations”, which are of a permanent nature. We in Pakistan take pride in our relations being as high as K-2 with China. This imagery is not just restricted to Pakistan. For China’s policymakers, “power and identity are both defined within the network of relations” for all its key bilateral relations. China has used its “participatory development” model with the developing world to its tremendous advantage. Its “relations” are built on economic participation, which creates an interdependency that cannot be beaten by knee-jerk “aid and run” operations of other Western powers. China’s emphasis on building infrastructure and jointly exploiting natural resources for the developing world are its secret to success at building lasting relationships. I personally have been a witness to their commitment to 24/7 development in distant areas of Pakistan. Unlike Western countries, it has little interest in interfering in the domestic democratic credentials of any country for obvious reasons. As such, it expects the same when it comes to its own domestic policies. It jealously guards its territorial integrity. As a recent example of this, one can turn towards Chinese criticism of Japanese upper house resolution and patronage of the Dalai Lama. In terms of China’s “responsible leader” role, it has demonstrated a balanced approach, as can be seen in its recent reactions towards the Syrian and Iranian crisis. For Syria, its four-point proposal “regarding ceasefire, end of violence and the implementation of political transition” is being welcomed as operable. Whilst for Iran, its belief in dialogue and cooperation is seen as an important balancing factor in the face of Western aggressive reaction. Its ability to draw all stakeholders into a communicative process is something Pakistan needs to mirror so that Iran’s isolation is reduced. Similarly, Chinese commitment to Palestine and Kashmir remains unflinching as well. Only recently, it has expressed its commitment to the “two-state solution” with its firm support to peace talks being the only correct way to achieving this solution. On nuclear disarmament, its position is unique. China believes that nuclear disarmament should follow the principles of “maintaining global strategic stability” and “undiminished security for all.“ This has far-reaching implications, which are in line with the harmonious world approach that China preaches so convincingly. Whilst China’s relations with the US remain the most crucial and difficult of all its strategic bilateral relations, these, perhaps, don’t have as much of an influence over China’s relations with the developing world. Pakistan’s relations, as mentioned in the earlier article, have to resolve the security and economic concerns that China has. The patience China has shown over the attacks on its nationals is unbelievable. Pakistan must not make the task of our super-efficient Ambassador to China any more difficult by not solving these security concerns. Whilst we appreciate the work of the “Joint Economic Commission” of under-seeing the second Five Year Development Plan ending in 2016, we need to aim for being China’s top trading partner. This can only be accomplished with economic stability in Pakistan. However hard our missions try at achieving this feat, the state of the crumbling economy at home makes it impossible. Only a responsive and responsible government, which curtails corruption, can make these plans a reality. Chinese interest in infrastructural project partnerships has not been given the highest priority in the economic managers priority lists. Certain incidences of extortion in the water and road projects by Pakistani officials have mired this strategic relationship, which needs to be closer due to our strategic proximity. All of this must be seen in a larger context. As younger leadership, we appreciate that the Chinese leadership’s belief in the “Scientific Outlook on Development” needs to be a shared objective in the Pak-China bilateral relations. Only when vision and mission is similar will the strategy be in coherence. There can be no disagreement on the fact that for development people need to come first; that income needs to increase for the majority of the people; that job opportunities need to increase; that unemployment needs to be reduced; that environment needs to be protected; that law and order needs to be maintained; and that education and culture needs to be advanced. There can also be no doubt that harmony is required between man and nature; between individual and other people; between the spiritual and the physical; and between current and future generations. We agree that the above “harmonious development” is the need of the region. It needs to be achieved by intertwining of economic and social interests between Pakistan and China. With China’s continued emphasis on scientific outlook, we at the PML-N are cognisant of our responsibility to emphasise and encourage “collaborative intertwining”, as the new buzz word in Pakistan-China bilateral relations with a special focus on the following areas: 1- Hydropower projects, including small dams and run-of-the-river projects; 2- North-South Trade Corridor for energy resource mobilisation; 3- Coal and mining projects; 4- Water treatment for waterworks; 5- Agriculture cropping projects for diversification of export strategy; 6- High-end technology and telecom joint venture collaborations; 7- Clean drinking water filtration plants; and 8- Youth collaborations to extend cultural, language and multimedia cooperation. As the great leader, Deng Xiaoping, said: “Unless you are confident of success, you can’t make proper policy decisions.” We are confident of success in our “collaborative intertwining” efforts of our two societies and we intend making proper policy decisions. In the final analysis, we look forward to a realisation of the real strategic relationship with China, which goes beyond how many times Pakistani leaders visit China. And which stresses the need for a shared 2030 development vision, which works beyond the fractured corrupt Pakistani institutions at fast track for our most treasured ally. We commit to “collaborative intertwining” of scientific outlook in Pakistan and China by keeping security and economic joint ventures as key priorities and leveraging on our “strategic proximity”. The writer is a former parliamentarian. Email: marvi.nmemon@gmail.com ==============
Russia has been roundly criticised in the Gulf for vetoing last month’s United Nations Security Council resolution on Syria. China, which also vetoed the resolution, has come in for much less flak. This may be partly because the Gulf Arab countries see Moscow rather than Beijing as Bashar al-Assad’s main supporter. But it is also because the Gulf and China have $90 billion a year in bilateral trade. It’s in the interests of neither that this is disrupted.
China and Gulf Arab countries value keeping politics out of business. The Syrian conflict, though, is testing that position. The Gulf nations want to see the end of the Assad regime: partly because of the killing of thousands of fellow Sunnis; and partly because their main enemy is Shi’ite Iran and the Assad regime is its top ally. Beijing, by contrast, strongly values the principle that countries should not intervene in the internal running of other states. It doesn’t want foreigners meddling in Tibet and Xinjiang.
The Middle Kingdom depends on the Middle East to meet its huge energy needs. The six-nation Gulf bloc supplied 34 percent of China’s total crude imports in 2011, according to Chinese customs data. That’s roughly three times the amount it imported from Iran.
But the Gulf can’t just cut off Beijing. Not only is China an important customer. It is, in turn, a supplier. For example, China is helping Saudi Arabia to increase the kingdom’s oil refining capacity and build giant railways connecting its holy cities. The pair also recently signed a civil nuclear cooperation agreement that supports Saudi’s ambitious domestic energy targets.
Beijing has softened its position somewhat on Syria in the past week. Not only did it express “deep disappointment” at Syria’s failure to allow the U.N. humanitarian aid chief to visit the country. It condemned “violence against innocent civilians” while reiterating its opposition to “armed interference or pushing for regime change”.
Beijing will probably hope it can hold this line and still keep good commercial links with the Gulf. But if the Syrian conflict escalates, it may need to modify its position further – perhaps even abstaining from rather than vetoing future resolutions criticising Assad.
==
Context News
China called on the Syrian government and all parties to cease all acts of violence, “particularly violence against innocent civilians”, in a statement on March 4. Beijing also urged the United Nations or an impartial body to distribute humanitarian aid to the Syrian people, while saying it opposed “anyone interfering in Syria’s internal affairs under the pretext of ’humanitarian’ issues.”
The foreign ministry statement also said: “China does not approve of armed interference or pushing for ’regime change’ in Syria, and believes that use or threat of sanctions does not help to resolve this issue appropriately.”
China and Russia joined other U.N. Security Council members on March 1 in expressing “deep disappointment” at Syria’s failure to allow the U.N. humanitarian aid chief Valerie Amos to visit the country and urged that she be allowed in immediately. In February, China and Russia vetoed a U.N. Security Council resolution that supported a call by the Arab League for Bashar al-Assad to step aside as president. ===================== China’s scientific outlook By: Marvi Memon | November 16, 2012 China’s foreign policy under its new leadership will be defined by an age old, well thought out strategic vision. As a great believer of China’s “scientific outlook” vision, I was most encouraged to see this continuity element in the full text of Resolution of the Eighteenth National Congress of the Communist Party of China on the Revised Constitution of the Communist Party of China adopted at the Eighteenth National Congress of the Communist Party of China on November 14, 2012: “The Scientific Outlook on Development is a scientific theory that is both in keeping with Marxism-Leninism, Mao Zedong Thought, Deng Xiaoping Theory and the important thought of Three Represents and is in step with the times.” Of perhaps all the emerging powers, China’s sense of direction is least known for knee-jerk reactions and most known for a long-term view of the world. Something Pakistani foreign policy actors need to learn from. Today’s world in Chinese terminology is called “yichao duoqiang”, which sees the world as unipolar as well as multipolar simultaneously. It is seen as a transitory process towards multipolarity. It is in this realistic context that Chinese foreign policy interventions will be relevant to all of us. This realistic acceptance is coupled with the theory of “shi”, which identifies the dominant power pole in the world order, and an assessment of whether the power configuration can bring any harm to China. From this derives the concept of following the general tendency, which will lead China higher in the power projections or “Shunshi erwei”. This process-oriented approach to foreign policy is unique to China and the new leadership is expected to make its first deliberations in the same light. The last policy direction clearly spelt out by President Hu in 2009 is worth remembering at this stage: (i) profound transformation; (ii) a harmonious world; (iii) common development; (iv) shared responsibility; and (v) active engagement. The general direction going forward will be basically the same. However, keeping in view the current international priorities, there will be a pull and push at China for a role, which is more attune with its new economic leading world status. Many in China believe that it should lead more and incorporate “retribution and punishment” in its foreign policy narrative. Its involvement in “global governance” discourse will certainly be encouraged by the EU, since its leadership role will be sought on issues like climate change, nuclear proliferation coupled with a commitment to the MDG goals of the UN. However, what is going to be watched most carefully going forward is whether there will be a more flexible approach to China’s “responsible stakeholder” role, which expects it to be more collaborative interventionist. China is unlikely to be pushed into any such misadventure by the West in its eagerness for asserting its global leadership role because it goes contradictory to its “shi” and identity. The unique nature of Chinese foreign policy is built around its emphasis on “relations”, which are of a permanent nature. We in Pakistan take pride in our relations being as high as K-2 with China. This imagery is not just restricted to Pakistan. For China’s policymakers, “power and identity are both defined within the network of relations” for all its key bilateral relations. China has used its “participatory development” model with the developing world to its tremendous advantage. Its “relations” are built on economic participation, which creates an interdependency that cannot be beaten by knee-jerk “aid and run” operations of other Western powers. China’s emphasis on building infrastructure and jointly exploiting natural resources for the developing world are its secret to success at building lasting relationships. I personally have been a witness to their commitment to 24/7 development in distant areas of Pakistan. Unlike Western countries, it has little interest in interfering in the domestic democratic credentials of any country for obvious reasons. As such, it expects the same when it comes to its own domestic policies. It jealously guards its territorial integrity. As a recent example of this, one can turn towards Chinese criticism of Japanese upper house resolution and patronage of the Dalai Lama. In terms of China’s “responsible leader” role, it has demonstrated a balanced approach, as can be seen in its recent reactions towards the Syrian and Iranian crisis. For Syria, its four-point proposal “regarding ceasefire, end of violence and the implementation of political transition” is being welcomed as operable. Whilst for Iran, its belief in dialogue and cooperation is seen as an important balancing factor in the face of Western aggressive reaction. Its ability to draw all stakeholders into a communicative process is something Pakistan needs to mirror so that Iran’s isolation is reduced. Similarly, Chinese commitment to Palestine and Kashmir remains unflinching as well. Only recently, it has expressed its commitment to the “two-state solution” with its firm support to peace talks being the only correct way to achieving this solution. On nuclear disarmament, its position is unique. China believes that nuclear disarmament should follow the principles of “maintaining global strategic stability” and “undiminished security for all.“ This has far-reaching implications, which are in line with the harmonious world approach that China preaches so convincingly. Whilst China’s relations with the US remain the most crucial and difficult of all its strategic bilateral relations, these, perhaps, don’t have as much of an influence over China’s relations with the developing world. Pakistan’s relations, as mentioned in the earlier article, have to resolve the security and economic concerns that China has. The patience China has shown over the attacks on its nationals is unbelievable. Pakistan must not make the task of our super-efficient Ambassador to China any more difficult by not solving these security concerns. Whilst we appreciate the work of the “Joint Economic Commission” of under-seeing the second Five Year Development Plan ending in 2016, we need to aim for being China’s top trading partner. This can only be accomplished with economic stability in Pakistan. However hard our missions try at achieving this feat, the state of the crumbling economy at home makes it impossible. Only a responsive and responsible government, which curtails corruption, can make these plans a reality. Chinese interest in infrastructural project partnerships has not been given the highest priority in the economic managers priority lists. Certain incidences of extortion in the water and road projects by Pakistani officials have mired this strategic relationship, which needs to be closer due to our strategic proximity. All of this must be seen in a larger context. As younger leadership, we appreciate that the Chinese leadership’s belief in the “Scientific Outlook on Development” needs to be a shared objective in the Pak-China bilateral relations. Only when vision and mission is similar will the strategy be in coherence. There can be no disagreement on the fact that for development people need to come first; that income needs to increase for the majority of the people; that job opportunities need to increase; that unemployment needs to be reduced; that environment needs to be protected; that law and order needs to be maintained; and that education and culture needs to be advanced. There can also be no doubt that harmony is required between man and nature; between individual and other people; between the spiritual and the physical; and between current and future generations. We agree that the above “harmonious development” is the need of the region. It needs to be achieved by intertwining of economic and social interests between Pakistan and China. With China’s continued emphasis on scientific outlook, we at the PML-N are cognisant of our responsibility to emphasise and encourage “collaborative intertwining”, as the new buzz word in Pakistan-China bilateral relations with a special focus on the following areas: 1- Hydropower projects, including small dams and run-of-the-river projects; 2- North-South Trade Corridor for energy resource mobilisation; 3- Coal and mining projects; 4- Water treatment for waterworks; 5- Agriculture cropping projects for diversification of export strategy; 6- High-end technology and telecom joint venture collaborations; 7- Clean drinking water filtration plants; and 8- Youth collaborations to extend cultural, language and multimedia cooperation. As the great leader, Deng Xiaoping, said: “Unless you are confident of success, you can’t make proper policy decisions.” We are confident of success in our “collaborative intertwining” efforts of our two societies and we intend making proper policy decisions. In the final analysis, we look forward to a realisation of the real strategic relationship with China, which goes beyond how many times Pakistani leaders visit China. And which stresses the need for a shared 2030 development vision, which works beyond the fractured corrupt Pakistani institutions at fast track for our most treasured ally. We commit to “collaborative intertwining” of scientific outlook in Pakistan and China by keeping security and economic joint ventures as key priorities and leveraging on our “strategic proximity”. The writer is a former parliamentarian. Email: marvi.nmemon@gmail.com ==============
Tuesday, January 31, 2012
China can be rich or neutral - not both
01 Feb 2012 03:27
Source: Reuters // Reuters
(Corrects figure in fifth paragraph to 1 mln, not 10 mln)
By John Foley
HONG KONG, Feb 1 (Reuters Breakingviews) - The kidnapping of 29 Chinese workers in Sudan shows that China's "don't intervene" policy is coming under strain. As the world's most populous country guns for the economic number one spot, it will not be as easy to keep out of conflicts. Even if China desires a softer alternative to the Pax Americana, history suggests that with power comes aggression.
Fence-sitting has been a central pillar of China's foreign policy since the 1950s, when Premier Zhou Enlai promised not to interfere in India's domestic business. Whereas the United States values governance and democracy, China prefers trade and investment. That strategy makes sense for a resource-hungry latecomer to the game of economic colonialism, even if it leaves the country open to accusations of turning a blind eye to undesirable regimes.
But not taking sides is not always enough. The kidnapping will push Beijing towards taking a more active role in the dispute over oil revenue between Sudan and newly independent South Sudan. Iran is another challenge. China can refuse to support Western sanctions, but it would not be happy about major disruptions to the oil market or a nuclear-armed Islamic Republic. With so much self-interest at stake, non-interference looks self-defeating.
If China finds a way to get rich and remain mostly peaceful, it would be good for everyone. So far the signs are good. President Hu Jintao talks of a "harmonious world", and has tackled regimes like Sudan's with aid and dialogue -- while sending peacekeeping troops to countries like East Timor, and deploying a naval force to the Aden Gulf in 2008 to protect merchant ships from pirates.
But the "Pax Sinensis" has two major challenges. One is China's skewed birth rate, which produces 1 million surplus boys every year. The other is its interconnectedness. China is already the world's largest importer of coal, soybeans and iron ore. When global markets are threatened, it can no longer sit by. Much as China might like to return to the way it was five hundred years ago -- rich, self-sufficient and largely left alone by the world -- that's no longer an option.
CONTEXT NEWS
-- China sent a team of officials to Sudan to seek the release of 29 workers being held by rebels on the border state of South Kordofan. A report by the Sudanese state news agency saying that 14 of the workers had been freed was denied by Chinese and Sudanese officials on Jan. 30.
-- The Philippines has held talks with the United States on expanding the American military presence in South-East Asia in response to China's growing assertiveness, the Washington Post reported on Jan. 26. Beijing and Manila both claim sovereignty over some islands in the South China Sea.
-- China invested $60 billion overseas in 2011, 1.8 percent more than the previous year, not including bank loans. That brought the total stock to $322 billion, according to the Ministry of Commerce. Investment into China totaled $116 billion in the same year.
-- Reuters: China sends team to Sudan seeking release of workers
-- For previous columns by the author, Reuters customers can click on (Editing by Edward Hadas and Martin Langfield)
================
China's outgoing leader sees unprecedented opportunity, unknown risks
Wed, Nov 07 20:52 PM EST
By Sui-Lee Wee and Ben Blanchard
BEIJING (Reuters) - China formally opened a congress of its ruling Communist Party on Thursday, ushering in a once-in-a-decade leadership change against a backdrop of growing social unrest, public anger at corruption and a yawning gap between rich and poor.
More than 2,000 hand-picked delegates gathered at Beijing's cavernous Great Hall of the People for the start of the week-long session, which will see President Hu Jintao give up his role as party chief to anointed successor Vice President Xi Jinping.
Xi then takes over state duties at the annual meeting of parliament in March.
"At present, as the global, national and our party's conditions continue to undergo profound changes, we are faced with unprecedented opportunities for development as well as risks and challenges unknown before," Hu said in the customary speech signaling the start of the meeting.The government has tightened security in the run-up to the congress, even banning the flying of pigeons in the capital, and has either locked up or expelled dozens of dissidents it fears could spoil the party. Security was especially tight on Thursday around the Great Hall and Tiananmen Square next door, the scene of pro-democracy protests in 1989 that were crushed by the military. Police dragged away a screaming protester as the Chinese national flag was raised at dawn. The party, which came to power in 1949 after a long and bloody civil war, has in recent years tied its legitimacy to economic growth and lifting hundreds of millions out of poverty. But China experts say that unless the new leadership pushes through stalled reforms, the nation risks economic malaise, deepening unrest, and perhaps even a crisis that could shake the party's grip on power. Advocates of reform are pressing Xi to cut back the privileges of state-owned firms, make it easier for rural migrants to settle permanently in cities, fix a fiscal system that encourages local governments to live off land expropriations and, above all, tether the powers of a state that they say risks suffocating growth and fanning discontent. The congress may also see cautious efforts to answer calls for more political reform, although nobody seriously expects a move towards full democracy. Party spokesman Cai Mingzhao said on Wednesday there would be greater efforts at promoting "inner-party democracy" - in other words, encouraging greater debate within the party - but that one-party rule was inviolate. "The leading position of the Communist Party in China is a decision made by history and by the people," he said. "Political system reform must suit China's national reality. We have to unswervingly stick to the right path blazed by the party." And that path includes control over what people can see and hear in the news and on the internet. "My internet has been cut off, I can't receive telephone calls and three people follow me when I leave the house to walk my dog," Xinna, the wife of one of China's longest-serving political prisoners, Mongol rights activist Hada, told Reuters. "All I want from this congress is my husband to be released and for our lives to get back to normal," she said from her home in the frigid northern Chinese city of Hohhot. A Tibetan rights group reported that three teenaged Tibetan monks in the southwestern province of Sichuan set themselves on fire on Wednesday in protest against Chinese rule, bringing to almost 70 the number of self-immolations by Tibetans in 18 months. China has branded the self-immolators "terrorists" and criminals and has blamed exiled Tibetans and the exiled Tibetan spiritual leader, the Dalai Lama, for inciting them. (Editing by Nick Macfie and Raju Gopalakrishnan) ============
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)